The man charged in the brutal killing of an 80-year-old Seattle woman walking her dogs has been deemed mentally unfit to stand trial, according to a judge’s ruling on Thursday.
Jahmed Haynes, who is facing multiple charges including first-degree murder and animal cruelty, appeared in court where the judge sided with recent findings from the Department of Social and Health Services indicating that he is currently not competent to aid in his defense.
Haynes is accused of violently carjacking and killing Ruth Dalton in August 2024 as she walked dogs in her Seattle neighborhood. Investigators allege that Haynes dragged Dalton with her own car and ran her over, killing her and one of the dogs she was walking.
Despite the passage of eight months since the arrest, Dalton’s family says justice still feels far away.
“It’s been eight months, and we’re no better off than we were when they arrested him,” said Melanie Roberts, Dalton’s granddaughter, who has been present at every court hearing.
According to court records, Haynes has a lengthy criminal record that includes eight prior felony convictions and a documented history of mental health challenges. Although a previous evaluation in December found him competent to stand trial, a recent 10-page report from state health officials reversed that decision, prompting Thursday’s ruling.
“The report provides extensive clinical evaluation, including history and recommended treatment,” the presiding judge stated, adding that Haynes currently lacks the capacity to assist his legal team and understand the proceedings. The report also included a list of prescribed medications that may help restore competency.
The judge restricted media from showing Haynes’ face in court to protect his right to a fair trial.
For Dalton’s family, the legal delays have only deepened their grief.
“It was her first birthday without her, our first Thanksgiving and Christmas without her. My first birthday without her. My daughter’s is coming up soon,” Roberts said. “It’s been a painful string of firsts we’ll feel for the rest of our lives.”
When asked what justice would look like, Roberts was unequivocal.
“Justice is him never breathing free air again. Whether he’s in a prison or a mental facility, he shouldn’t be back on the streets.”
The court has ordered a 90-day restoration period, after which Haynes’ mental fitness will be re-evaluated. The next hearing is scheduled for July 24.
